Trading journal: what it is, what to write and how to review it
A trading journal on a real stock: Visa, 2024
A trading journal is the written record of every trade: the plan before entering (entry, stop loss, target or take profit), the risk, the exit, the reason, the mistakes. It measures what you do in a single unit: the multiple of your risk, R.
Choose a trade to read its calculations. The result in R: 1: −1.00R. 2: +2.00R.
| Trade | Date | Direction | Entry | Stop | Target | 1R | Exit | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Short | $267.69 | $277.26 | $248.55 | $9.57 | $277.26 | −1.00R | |
| 2 | Long | $255.43 | $249.93 | $266.43 | $5.50 | $266.43 | +2.00R |
These are examples to show the calculations, not trades that were executed. The rule: stop beyond the last confirmed swing, target at +2R, exit at the first level touched.
Why keep a trading journal
Memory keeps the good trades and loses the others. A journal keeps them all, on the same terms. This holds for swing trading and for day trading: the number of rows changes, the columns do not.
Fig. 1 · The record of a hypothetical trade
- The plan is written first. Entry, stop and target are in the journal while the result is still unknown.
- The exit is written later. The calculation in R compares what happened with the risk decided at the start.
- Reason and mistake are words. These two columns let you group the rows when you review them.
Fig. 2 · Same gain, different result
- Money does not say how much was at risk. The two trades gain the same, but the second one risked four times as much.
- R puts them on one scale. The multiple of the risk compares a cheap stock with an expensive one, a small position with a large one.
Fig. 3 · Long and short: the same formula
- The signs do the rest. In short selling the exit is below the entry and the stop above: two negative differences give a positive result.
- One column is enough. There is no need for two calculations, and in a spreadsheet the formula is the same on every row.
result in R = (exit − entry) ÷ (entry − stop)
The fields a trading journal needs
ten columns, six groups1Who and when
- Date, ticker, direction.
- Enough to find the trade again on the chart.
2The plan
- Entry, stop loss, target or take profit.
- Written before entering, and not touched afterwards.
3The risk in R
- 1R is the distance between entry and stop.
- Written in money per share: it is the unit of everything else.
4The exit
- The real price and date, even if different from the plan.
- The result in R comes from here, and the sheet calculates it.
5The reason
- Why you entered, always in the same words.
- βBreakoutβ spelled three ways makes three different groups.
6The mistakes
- What did not go according to plan.
- A few words, always the same: easier to count when they come back.
A trading journal template, ready to use
fill it in here, it recalculates by itself, download it as CSVSample rows, not results. The first two come from the chart above, the others are made up to show the calculations. None is an executed trade and none describes a strategy: clear them and write your own.
| # | Date | Ticker | Direction | Entry | Stop | Target | Exit | 1R | Result | Reason | Mistakes | remove the row |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 9.57 | −1.00R | ||||||||||
| 2 | 5.50 | +2.00R | ||||||||||
| 3 | 1.00 | +2.00R | ||||||||||
| 4 | 2.00 | −1.00R | ||||||||||
| 5 | 1.00 | −1.60R | ||||||||||
| 6 | 1.00 | −1.00R | ||||||||||
| 7 | 0.60 | +2.00R | ||||||||||
| 8 | 2.00 | +0.50R | ||||||||||
| 9 | 1.00 | −1.00R | ||||||||||
| 10 | 0.40 | −1.60R | ||||||||||
| 11 | 0.60 | +2.00R | ||||||||||
| 12 | 1.00 | −1.00R |
This journal is not saved anywhere: not sent, not kept in the browser. Reload the page and the sample comes back. To keep it, download it: your browser writes the file. In the CSV the calculated columns are formulas: for a new row, copy a whole row.
Fig. 4 · The trades in a row and the average result
- The average result is the expectancy. It says what a trade is worth on average, in multiples of the risk.
- The win rate alone is not enough. You can win rarely and stay above zero, or win often and stay below.
Fig. 5 · The equity curve
- Each point is a journal row. On each trade the capital changes by the result in R times the risk chosen, here 1% to start with.
- The fall counts as much as the finish. The largest fall from the peak is the drawdown measured in R: how much you have to bear before coming back.
Deeper dives: Drawdown.
Interactive exerciseFill in the journal: risk in R and result in R
Visa, 2024: three trades on the real chart- Read entry, stop and exit on the chart.
- Write 1R, in money per share.
- Write the result in R and have it checked.
The checker accepts 1R within 0.01 and the result within 0.05 R. The swing used for the stop is the amber dot.
How to review the journal: mistakes and trade types
from the template rows: they change when you change themFig. 6 · By trade type
- Add up by reason. Next to the total there is always how many trades made it.
- With few rows it is only arithmetic. Nothing can be concluded from these hypothetical numbers: the next section says why.
Fig. 7 · By mistake
- Mistakes have a price. In the sample βStop movedβ comes back 2 times and weighs −3.20R.
- Fix what comes back. A mistake seen once is an episode, one that returns is a rule to write down.
How many trades before drawing conclusions
Take a hypothetical coin: it wins 40% of the time and pays +2R, loses the rest and costs −1R. We know its true average result by arithmetic: +0.20R. What does someone keeping it in a journal see?
Fig. 8 · Six journals of 20 trades, the same coin
- Same rule, opposite endings. After 20 trades the six journals finish between +10R and −5R, and the coin is always the same.
- Chance weighs more than the rule. The dashed line is the expected result: no journal follows it, they only wander around it.
Fig. 9 · Where the average result falls, nine journals out of ten
- A small sample cannot tell. With 10 trades the measured average can sit between −0.40R and +1.10R: both zero and the true value are inside.
- The range narrows slowly. The same coin ends below zero in 17.6% of journals with 30 trades and 9.1% of those with 100: exact binomial arithmetic.
The mistakes in keeping a trading journal
1Writing only the good ones
- Skipped losses change every statistic.
- One row for every trade, no exceptions.
2Counting in money
- The same amount can be worth a different R.
- Read the result in R, money comes after.
3Rewriting the stop
- The risk is the one decided at the entry.
- If the stop was moved, 1R does not change: note the mistake.
4Concluding from few rows
- Five good trades say nothing.
- First check how many there are, then how they did.
5Filling it in from memory
- Later on, the entry always looks better.
- Write the plan before entering, the exit the same day.
6Never reading it again
- A journal nobody rereads is just an archive.
- Pick a day and look at what comes back.
Deeper dives: Where to put the stop loss · Where to put the take profit · The types of orders · How to choose stocks.
Where to go from here
Risk managementThe other lessons in the Β«Risk managementΒ» section
Stop loss
- an order that closes the position at a level decided before entering
- below the last swing low, a support level, a trendline, or two ATRs away
- pick the entry day on a real chart and count the shares
Take profit
- a limit order that closes at a gain, at a level decided before entering
- at a multiple of the risk, below resistance, on a chart pattern or with the ATR
- click the level on a real chart: at least twice the risk and below resistance
Drawdown
- the percentage distance between the price and its previous high
- maximum drawdown is the deepest fall of the period, from the high to the following low
- after losing 50% you need 100% to break even: the asymmetry is arithmetic
Stop limit order
- how a stop limit order works, plus market, limit, stop, trailing stop and OCO
- where an order fills in the book, what slippage is, what happens in a gap
- simulate an order on a real chart and pick the right one in four scenarios
Frequently asked questions
What is a trading journal?
The written record of every trade: the plan before entering, the risk, the exit, the reason and the mistakes. It shows what you actually do, without relying on memory.
What should a trading journal include?
Date, ticker, direction, entry, stop, target, risk in R, exit, reason and mistakes. The plan is written before entering, the exit when the trade closes.
How do you calculate R-multiples and expectancy?
The result in R is (exit β entry) Γ· (entry β stop): with entry 255.43, stop 249.93 and exit 266.43 it gives +2.00R. Expectancy is the average result per trade: in the sample on this page 41.7% Γ 1.70R β 58.3% Γ 1.17R = +0.03R.
How many trades do you need to evaluate a trading journal?
There is no magic number. With a hypothetical coin worth +0.20R per trade, nine journals out of ten with 30 trades show an average result between −0.20R and +0.60R: on few rows chance weighs more than the rule.
Method and sources
| Source |
|---|
| Van K. Tharp, Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom: the initial risk as the unit of measure, R-multiples, expectancy. |
| John J. Murphy, Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets: chapter 16, money management and trading tactics. |
The chart uses the Visa sessions from our archive, adjusted for dividends and corporate actions and rounded to the cent. A swing is the most extreme high or low of the five sessions before and after. The template rows after the first two and figures 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9 are hypothetical. This guide explains how the tools work: it does not contain investment recommendations and promises no returns. Our method · license · report an error.
DOMINA’s stock pages, indices and commodities are rebuilt every night. Leave your email: we write to you when the picture changes.
No third-party advertising. Unsubscribe with one click. Go to the platform →With your consent we use Google Analytics cookies to count visits. If you decline, the page works the same and no measurement cookie is set. Cookie policy